It’s been a fun year of travel for me. This was one of my best years for international travel mainly due to the fact I spent much of the year in Cape Town, South Africa tagging along while my girlfriend was getting a graduate degree at the University of Cape Town. Many of the flights were very long so I was able to experience new long hauls airline offerings. I also had many long layovers, mainly in the Middle East. As I like to do every year, I compile all my flight legs, new airlines, miles flown, new destinations and new aircraft. Then I like to crown a winner in the destination, airline and aircraft division. It’s fun to look back at the end of the year and revisit all your experiences. It also gives you a chance to get excited for the future. Where will you go in 2015? Read more
Archive for Flight Review
United 1241 – DEN to LAX – Background
Having just flown from DEN to LAX on Frontier a few weeks ago, I decided to take my next flight back home on United 1241 to write a comparison blog. I have to admit, even though I’m a peon on United (a lowly Silver status), it felt 1000X better than being cattle-prodded through the Frontier low-cost carrier mentality. That said, I paid $100 more for the flight – but with that I got a free checked bag both ways (due to my elite status), early boarding, and in-flight beverages. And, I of course had the opportunity to accrue more United miles towards Gold status – which I may be able to reach this year with the help of my United Explorer credit card, which counts towards elite status (up to Gold).
This was one of those obligatory flights that I had to purchase – Thanksgiving (Christmas being the second) – to spend the holiday with my parents, John and Jody, in Los Angeles. This United flight sure did not beat my parents’ recent private flight experience – but hey, we can’t all travel like the rich and famous.
I booked through United.com because it was slightly cheaper than Orbitz – enough so that the Orbitz Rewards bucks became negligible. My total fare was $240.20.
|1 Adult (18-64)||$212.00|
One of the other reasons I wanted to fly United was because of the in-flight Wi-Fi – I can’t lose a second during the day to get work done, and this was no exception. It turns out the Wi-Fi, as usual, was lackluster – but I’ll get in to that more later. Here’s the pre-flight e-mail teaser I got, explaining that in-flight Wi-Fi would be available to purchase. It was confusing though, because United made it seem as if you could purchase Wi-Fi at a discount in advance – but it turns out I was only able to purchase DirecTV in advance, not Wi-Fi.
I did pretty well on airfare considering it was Thanksgiving – here’s a blog I recently wrote rolling up Thanksgiving fare data from Hopper. My flight (Tuesday before Thanksgiving through Tuesday after Thanksgiving) was slightly higher than average, but considering it’s over a holiday, it’s to be expected. My flight was actually only 9% above average, which means I did well, considering 2013 industry data shows 35% higher fares for holidays in 2013 – source Hopper.
United 1241 Departure Airport, Check-in, and Boarding
I used The Parking Spot again. It’s quite convenient and they run a well-oiled machine. Very little slack or wait time. All business, no party – at least usually. This time was a bit unusual because I had to wait about 10 minutes for a shuttle to pick me up and bring to me from where I dropped my car off to the Main DEN Terminal. Some folks waiting with me said they had to wait for 20 minutes. I still think this is the way to go – with my work discount I parking comes to about $6/day, which is cheaper than taking a cab (from downtown Denver to the Airport it’s about $80) – unless you’re staying away more than 20 days or so, and the economics begin to break-even.
We’ve already reviewed DEN extensively here. However, for Thanksgiving, I have to say it felt empty, and security was light. Dropping off my bag with United was painless – there was no wait since I could use the automatic bag drop kiosk, as I checked-in in advance the night before. The flight was really packed!
I was also able to find myself a better seat – in an exit row.
After I walked around the main terminal and took pictures for a few hours, I decided to try going through security on the Northside of the Main Concourse, at the end of the Concourse A walkway. At Denver Airport, there are actually 3 security entrances – the two obvious ones in the Main Terminal, North and South side – and then a 3rd across the walkway going to Concourse A on the North side.
This walkway, incidentally, always has great exhibits and art – during my visit, a Beer exhibit was featured in honor of Denver Beer Festival in October.
The wait times at this security checkpoint are always shorter, AND there is a TSA Pre-check line. I chatted with one of the TSA agents at this Concourse A Security checkpoint, and she said that the only time the line gets slower is when they’re doing training exercises (not frequently). She also mentioned it can get quite crowded for crew members. However, it’s clearly a great 3rd option for the general public – and you can always check security wait times at the 3 security checkpoints here.
United 1241 Flight Details
- Route: DEN to LAX via CONNR3 DBL J60 HEC RIIVR2
- Airline:United 1241 – United’s IATA code is UA
- Departure Gate: B39
- Arrival Gate: 72
- Scheduled:5:30 PM
- Actual Flight time: 5:42 PM
- Boarding time: 4:55 PM
- Scheduled Arrival Time:7:04 PM
- Actual Arrival Time: 6:36 PM
- Travel Time: 1h 34m
- Altitude: Filed at 34,000 feet
- Baggage Claim:Carousel 1
- Aircraft type:Boeing 737-900, Tail number 3445
- Distance traveled: Direct – 862 sm; Planned: 880 sm; Flown: 880 sm;
- Class: Economy
- Baggage cost: Free due to Silver Status, otherwise $25 for a checked bag
- Seat: 25A
- Upgrade: Check-in the night before in Economy, but was able to upgrade to an exit row at the bag drop counter at the airport. Added to the complimentary upgrade list due to status; however, no upgrade given.
- Load factor: 79% full on route (average). 167 (20 United First, 147 United Economy)
- Average one-way fare: $138.43
Incidentally, I pulled this report from FareReport.com which gives some comparisons between United and Frontier on this same route.
U.S. Department of Transportation’s Consumer Fare Report:
Route: Approximately 862 miles each way with 2016 daily passengers
Fares: Average one-way fare: $177
Average cost per mile: $0.21
|Airline with the Largest Market Share: United||Airline with the Lowest Average Fare: Frontier|
|Average Fare: $202||Average Fare: $153|
|Market Share: 44%||Market Share: 32%|
United 1241 Flight
Nothing was particularly remarkable about boarding and take-off, other than boarding seemed more crowded and disorganized than usual – probably due to the holiday rush and the small amount of space at the particular gate we were assigned at DEN.
I was able to grab a picture of the new United In-Flight entertainment software module at the front of the plane, and a picture of the door of the plane that showed that there would indeed be in-flight Wi-Fi.
We seemed to board and push-back more on less on time. I boarded with group 2 so I was able to snap some quick pictures of the cabin, overhead bins, and seats before the plane filled up. Since I had an exit row seat, there was much more legroom than I was used to.
We also had the same in-flight entertainment and charger configuration (impossible to find, buried under the seat) that I’m use to on United 737-900 flights.
My particular entertainment system was broken, but this didn’t matter as my plan was to pay for in-flight Wi-Fi and be productive for the flight. Finally, the seat-back tray was a little uncomfortable – since it was an exit row with additional legroom, the tray didn’t actually pull out far enough so it was uncomfortable NOT over my lap, which also made it hard to use the laptop on the tray. It either needed to be longer, or come out further to be in a more functional position. There also wasn’t enough room on the tray for my sparkling water, can, and the laptop – but I guess that’s no different than usual. Hey, at least United gives free sodas still, unlike the recent DEN-LAX flight I took on Frontier.
United 1241 In-Flight Wi-Fi
I had initially purchased Wi-Fi for 1 hour. It took 15 minutes to get it to connect, having to continuously enter my credit card information until finally the United system didn’t time out the transaction went through.
Incidentally, I got charged for 3 separate transactions – and had to open a dispute process later on with United to get a refund for $2 of my $3 for the 1 hour of Wi-Fi I was trying to purchase. #epicfail
Here’s what it looked like after I finally was connected:
Then, after about 20 minutes to access, Wi-Fi went dead – no signal at all. At that point, I started browsing the free pages that supposedly I could browse without paid Wi-Fi…but even those weren’t working!
Luckily, I noticed it went down, but still had to wait about 5 minutes for the signal to come back up. No doubt I will be charged for those 5 minutes without connectivity. I paid for an hour of service but with all the hassle, delay in being able to log in, and sporadic behavior in between – I got only about 45 minutes worth of solid email-productivity Wi-Fi. On top of that, My gmail wouldn’t work.
One cool thing about in-flight Wi-Fi was the ability to track my flight real-time with FlightAware.
Would I have paid the same $1 for 45 minutes? You betcha. But I could have done without the stress and hassle in between!
Overall Grade – United 1241
Similar to my last United review, where I gave my BOS-DEN United flight a C+, I continued to be extremely disappointed with the Wi-Fi. This time, at least I was able to access Wi-Fi – but it was still inconsistent, flaky, hard to set up and pay for, and ultimately I felt like I was cheated.
For this reason, coupled with the fact that my in-flight entertainment system would not turn on, I gave this particular flight a B.
This negative experience was balanced out by the positive experience of United allowing me to upgrade to an exit-row seat at check-in, and for getting in early.